What Happened Between Catherine and Jonathan in Disclaimer? How Did Jonathan Get the Cut on His Arm in Disclaimer?

What Happened Between Catherine and Jonathan in Disclaimer? (Spoiler Alert!)

Catherine and Jonathan had a serious relationship in Disclaimer that ended tragically when Jonathan died while trying to save Catherine's son. Catherine watched Jonathan struggle in the water but didn't help, thinking his death would be better for her. This shows that Catherine cared little for Jonathan, despite their past affair.

Jonathan's mysterious cut and his tragic death remain unclear, but it hints at a deeper truth involving Catherine. The events between them were very traumatic, and Catherine's side of the story hasn't fully been told yet.(Source: Screen Rant)

How Did Jonathan Get the Cut on His Arm in Disclaimer? (Spoiler Alert!)

In the series Disclaimer, Jonathan has a mysterious cut on his arm that raises questions about his death. Stephen, his father, first notices the cut when he identifies Jonathan's body. There are different theories about how he got it. One idea is that he was cut by a pocketknife given to him by his father, Stephen.

Another possibility is that Catherine might have accidentally scratched him during their relationship. The cut suggests there is more to Jonathan's story than what Catherine says. It might mean he didn’t just drown but could have been harmed before he died. The true details of his death are still unclear.

Disclaimer Season 1 Episodes 4 Endings Explained

By the end of episode 4 of Disclaimer season 1, we see that Catherine is involved in Jonathan’s death. She watched him struggle in the water but did not tell the lifeguards who were close by. She also lied to the police and said she had never seen Jonathan before, which makes it clear that she is hiding something.

The new episodes also show how Robert, Catherine's husband, is feeling. We see flashbacks that show Stephen's sadness after losing both Jonathan and Nancy. These scenes help us understand how much pain these characters are going through after these tragic events.

What motivated Catherine to seek Jonathan's death?

In episodes 3 and 4 of Disclaimer, we learn why Catherine might want Jonathan dead. Catherine met Jonathan in Italy when he took her picture. They spent time together, and she seduced him, sharing her secrets and desires.

Although it was meant to be a one-time fling, Jonathan fell in love with her and wanted to go to London with her. When her son Nicholas drifted into the sea, Jonathan jumped in to save him. Catherine saw him struggling but did not help. She thought Jonathan’s death would hide her affair and protect her marriage.

What happens with Robert?

In the premiere of Disclaimer, Robert leaves after confronting Catherine about the photos from Stephen. In episodes 3 and 4, Robert feels regret for choosing Catherine over his family. He becomes jealous after learning about Catherine's affair with Jonathan and decides to take action.

Robert brings their son Nicholas back to their apartment, against Catherine's wishes. By the end of episode 4, he throws Catherine out, wanting to connect with Nicholas, whom he thinks may have known about the affair and its impact on their family.

What is Stephen doing now?

The new episodes of Disclaimer season 1 show how sad Stephen Brigstocke feels after Jonathan drowned and Nancy died from cancer. Stephen found a book called The Perfect Stranger that Nancy wrote. He published it and gave copies to Catherine, Robert, and Nicholas. Now, he is thinking about writing another book.

In episode 4, Stephen decides to write about a teenage boy. He wants to make a fake Facebook profile for this character. He might be trying to connect with Nicholas on Facebook. We will have to watch the next episodes to find out more.

Disclaimer

Disclaimer is a psychological thriller miniseries by Alfonso Cuarón. It is based on a 2015 book by Renée Knight. Cate Blanchett plays a documentarian who must face her past. The show also stars Kevin Kline, Sacha Baron Cohen, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Louis Partridge, and Lesley Manville.