Presumed Innocent Episode 8 Ending Explained, Who Killed Carolyn Polhemus?

Presumed Innocent Episode 8 Ending Explained

In the final episode of "Presumed Innocent," the true identity of Carolyn Polhemus' murderer is unveiled. It is discovered that Jaden Sabich, the daughter of Rusty's ex-wife, is the one who killed Carolyn. This twist was unexpected for many viewers who might have thought other characters, like Rusty's ex-wife Barbara, were the culprits.

The episode concludes with lively music and a sequence showcasing the main characters from the show. It's important to mention that "Presumed Innocent" is a legal drama series centered around Rusty Sabich, a defense attorney accused of killing his colleague and lover, Carolyn Polhemus.

(Source: Sportskeeda)

Episode 8 Recap

In the final episode of "Presumed Innocent," called "The Verdict," the narrative reaches its peak, unveiling the secrets of Carolyn Polhemus' death. The episode resumes from where the last one ended, with Rusty Sabich accusing his wife, Barbara, of Carolyn's murder. Rusty discovers Barbara's suitcase in their bedroom and confronts her regarding it. Barbara reveals that her therapist suggested she prepare a "go bag" in case Rusty were to cheat on her again, but Rusty still suspects her of being the murderer.

As the episode unfolds, there are unexpected developments as the true intentions and deeds of the characters are exposed. Tommy Molto, Rusty's long-standing adversary and the prosecutor in the case, is eliminated as a suspect. The episode concludes with a Thanksgiving scene, depicting the family's unity and joy as they share a meal together.

Who Killed Carolyn Polhemus?

In the TV show "Presumed Innocent" on Apple TV+, the identity of the person who killed Carolyn Polhemus is not directly revealed. The storyline appears to sow doubt among numerous characters, making it difficult to pinpoint the true murderer.

Potential culprits discussed in the analysis include Raymond Horgan, who is also best friends with Rusty and works as his attorney, and Tommy Molto, who represents the prosecutor in the case. Yet, it's crucial to remember that the show might diverge from the book and film versions, suggesting that the murderer in the series might not always be the same person as in the other media portrayals.

Is Rusty Found Guilty of Carolyn’s Murder?

In the midst of intense tension, the clerk announces Rusty's acquittal for Carolyn's murder, bringing a flood of relief to his loved ones. Rusty then makes a statement to the press, declaring his innocence and his lack of involvement in the crime, while acknowledging that justice was not fully served for Carolyn. "Her murderer remains at large, and the case remains unsolved," he stated. "She deserved a better outcome."

As the news unfolds, Tommy appears defeated. However, Nico reassures him, calling the case a "remarkable" one and encouraging him to let go of Carolyn and Rusty. So, did Tommy commit the murder? It seems so... until Rusty finds Barbara's suitcase filled with belongings at his house and confronts her while she's working out in the garage. She reveals that the suitcase and escape plan were recommended by a therapist, suggesting it could be a plan for future escape attempts. He is deeply affected by her confession but chooses not to defend himself, saying, "I knew from the start. And then I didn't know. And then I knew again for sure." For those new to the "First-Time Presumed Innocent" series, the ambiguous accusation might seem strange — how could Rusty's wife have committed the murder? After all, it was done in the film. This raises questions about whether the series is faithful to the original story.

Presumed Innocent

The show is called Presumed Innocent and it's a legal drama series from the United States, made by David E. Kelley. It's based on the 1987 book of the same name by Scott Turow, which was the first book to be turned into a TV show, after a movie version came out in 1990 with Harrison Ford and Brian Dennehy in the lead roles. It first aired on Apple TV+ on June 12, 2024. Later that year, in July, the show got a green light for a second season.

Cast

Streaming Platforms

"Presumed Innocent" Episode 8 is available for streaming on Apple TV+..